Apr 14th, 2010 by ravi
Sometimes Hitchens does serve a purpose!

He’s often your go to man if you want a can of whup-ass opened up (unless it needs to be opened up on George Galloway, which Hitchens is not up to). Like here, with D’Souza:


Read the full post and comments »
Apr 13th, 2010 by ravi
Why Dawkins and Dennett harm atheism

Dawkins by most accounts is not a philosophical heavyweight, preferring to peddle Biology in best-selling sound bites, unless occupied with furthering his false claim to the mantle of atheism. The heavy lifting on his behalf and that of their joint cause (New Atheism) is usually performed by Daniel Dennett. But in the video below, Dinesh D’Souza, Reaganophile, defender of Christianity, and all-around loathsome character, runs rings around Dennett in a debate at Dennett’s own home turf, Tufts University. Behold the spluttering philosopher:

in which Dennett, when not spluttering, attempts to address D’Souza’s points using every possible rhetorical sleight of hand. Such as appeals to authority:

I am not a physicist, but I know X, and if he were here he would agree with me…

I have spent years working on this stuff…

What is particularly pathetic, and revealing, is that D’Souza at times attempts coherent argument whereas Dennett opens with some photographs and slides ridiculing Mormonism and other oddities of religion, while accusing D’Souza of creating caricatures, dismissing D’Souza’s reference to the anthropic principle as a “cartoon version” (and dismissing it out of hand because neither he nor D’Souza are physicists or cosmologists).

This exchange is revealing because the techniques and argumentation of Dawkins, Dennett and Hitchens exposes their dogmatic commitments, and the lack of the very rationality in debate that they claim to defend as a system of knowledge.

All of which undermines the cause and interest of good Old Atheism.


Read the full post and comments »
Apr 5th, 2010 by ravi
The messy business of “freedom” — WikiLeaks video of Iraq attack

WikiLeaks has released this video of a US helicopter attack in Iraq:


Read the full post and comments »